TheEEStory.com

News, reviews and Discussion of EEStor Inc.
Zenn bolsters their drivetrain engineering credibility, possibly UFC cred as well « Zenn Motor Company « Financial
 
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:24pm #1
ShortEE
EEcclesiastical
Mrschadenfreude2
Registered: Apr, 2009
Last visit: 7 minutes ago
Posts: 1046

Sometime recently, likely in the fall of 2009, ZMC hired Jane Huang, PMP MBA P.ENG.

That's certified Project Manager, Master of Business Administration, and Professional Engineer.

Her previous experience?
* Senior Project Manager/Engineer at General Motors
* Business and Operation at General Motors
* Project Engineer, Powertrain Integration at General Motors

And, to top it all off, she has a black belt in karate.

I guess ZMC is really serious about trying to fool people into thinking that they are developing drivetrains.

Offline


Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:30pm #2
broschultz
EEluminated
Registered: May, 2009
Last visit: 3 hours ago
Posts: 532

Do you think Jane would take the job without seeing an eesu?

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:31pm #3
dfwrunner
EEluminated
Eesuins
Registered: Aug, 2008
Last visit: 14 hours ago
Posts: 575

ShortEE wrote:

Sometime recently, likely in the fall of 2009, ZMC hired Jane Huang, PMP MBA P.ENG.

That's certified Project Manager, Master of Business Administration, and Professional Engineer.

Her previous experience?
* Senior Project Manager/Engineer at General Motors
* Business and Operation at General Motors
* Project Engineer, Powertrain Integration at General Motors

And, to top it all off, she has a black belt in karate.

I guess ZMC is really serious about trying to fool people into thinking that they are developing drivetrains.

A lot of evidence of marketing and project management, not so much engineering...


LMS - 5.32853173672 (A True Skeptic (TM) is objective)
TBS - 10.0
Elevated from y_po idiot to moron, 11/8/09, 8:35 CST

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:36pm #4
unipres
EElevated
Mikes2
Registered: Jul, 2009
Last visit: 2 hours ago
Posts: 495

broschultz wrote:

Do you think Jane would take the job without seeing an eesu?

I suspect that a lot of people at Zenn have not seen an EESU.


I do not debate to prove you are wrong, but rather to test that my convictions live up to your scrutiny. --me

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:36pm #5
ShortEE
EEcclesiastical
Mrschadenfreude2
Registered: Apr, 2009
Last visit: 7 minutes ago
Posts: 1046

dfwrunner wrote:

A lot of evidence of marketing and project management, not so much engineering...

Um...

Senior Project Manager/Engineer at General Motors
Business and Operation at General Motors
Project Engineer, Powertrain Integration at General Motors

Seriously, not so much engineering? And where do you get marketing from?

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:45pm #6
Y_Po
EExhilarating
Zawy_y_go
Registered: May, 2009
Posts: 3239

"Professional Engineer"? what does it even mean?


Q: What would happen if you give 12V battery and two 6V light bulbs to Weir/Nelson?

A: They will wait 8 years for 12V➜6V DC-DC converter.

http://theeestory.com/topics/3687
http://theeestory.com/topics/2105
http://theeestory.com/topics/4835

Online
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:48pm #7
RogerJ
EExtensive
Registered: Nov, 2008
Last visit: Fri, 03 Sep 2010
Posts: 28

Y_Po wrote:

"Professional Engineer"? what does it even mean?

Per wikipedia
"Professional Engineer (see below for various abbreviations) is the term for registered or licensed engineers in some countries who are permitted to offer their professional services directly to the public.

The term Professional Engineer and the actual practice of professional engineering is legally defined and protected by a government body. In some jurisdictions only registered or licensed Professional Engineers are permitted to use the title, or to practice Professional Engineering.

The earmark that distinguishes a licensed/registered Professional Engineer is the authority to sign and seal or "stamp" engineering documents (reports, drawings, and calculations) for a study, estimate, design or analysis, thus taking legal responsibility for it."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional_Engineer

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:52pm #8
brianjones
EErudite
Registered: Nov, 2009
Last visit: 3 hours ago
Posts: 72

ShortEE wrote:

dfwrunner wrote:

A lot of evidence of marketing and project management, not so much engineering...

Um...

Senior Project Manager/Engineer at General Motors
Business and Operation at General Motors
Project Engineer, Powertrain Integration at General Motors

Seriously, not so much engineering? And where do you get marketing from?


Assuming she wasn't just an absolute 'catch', to grab on a chance, this one, at least, seems inconceivable if Zenn (a) is not reasonably sure of an EESU to power the train she's supposed to integrate, and (b) reasonably clear on its specs.
(Unless of course she's a Popular Science specialist.)
Which seems to shift the weight of skepticism pretty firmly and solely onto Eestor deluding ZENN, themselves, or both. No way to know that one (beyond the usual circumstantials), but the weight, for me, is shifting firmly away from ZENN.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 1:55pm #9
Fibb
EEuphoric
Av-13927
Registered: Jul, 2009
Last visit: 43 minutes ago
Posts: 833

http://ca.linkedin.com/in/janehuangpmp

http://www.mie.utoronto.ca/images/alumni/jane.jpg


Dick Weir will not go quietly in the night, he will bring forth the new EESU, for EESU reveal day is our Independence day! - Futureman 100/10

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:03pm #10
brianjones
EErudite
Registered: Nov, 2009
Last visit: 3 hours ago
Posts: 72

Fibb222 wrote:

http://ca.linkedin.com/in/janehuangpmp

http://www.mie.utoronto.ca/images/alumni/jane.jpg

...and she looks to be Chinese, which wouldn't hurt.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:05pm #11
Fibb
EEuphoric
Av-13927
Registered: Jul, 2009
Last visit: 43 minutes ago
Posts: 833

brianjones wrote:

Fibb222 wrote:

http://ca.linkedin.com/in/janehuangpmp

http://www.mie.utoronto.ca/images/alumni/jane.jpg

...and she looks to be Chinese, which wouldn't hurt.

as in "fluent in English, Chinese(Mandarin and Cantonese) and basic French."


Dick Weir will not go quietly in the night, he will bring forth the new EESU, for EESU reveal day is our Independence day! - Futureman 100/10

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:16pm #12
Y_Po
EExhilarating
Zawy_y_go
Registered: May, 2009
Posts: 3239

too pretty to be a real engineer

Last edited Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:28pm by Y_Po


Q: What would happen if you give 12V battery and two 6V light bulbs to Weir/Nelson?

A: They will wait 8 years for 12V➜6V DC-DC converter.

http://theeestory.com/topics/3687
http://theeestory.com/topics/2105
http://theeestory.com/topics/4835

Online
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:17pm #13
brianjones
EErudite
Registered: Nov, 2009
Last visit: 3 hours ago
Posts: 72

Fibb222 wrote:

brianjones wrote:

Fibb222 wrote:

http://ca.linkedin.com/in/janehuangpmp

http://www.mie.utoronto.ca/images/alumni/jane.jpg

...and she looks to be Chinese, which wouldn't hurt.

as in "fluent in English, Chinese(Mandarin and Cantonese) and basic French."

A moment of silence for Poor Jane, who's traded a promising career for hot-shirts and delusions.
If she'd only listened to CRJohn.
Even I could'a told her, who've never seen anything.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:19pm #14
brianjones
EErudite
Registered: Nov, 2009
Last visit: 3 hours ago
Posts: 72

Y_Po wrote:

too pretty to be a real enhineer

Now that's dirty.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:19pm #15
dfwrunner
EEluminated
Eesuins
Registered: Aug, 2008
Last visit: 14 hours ago
Posts: 575

ShortEE wrote:

dfwrunner wrote:

A lot of evidence of marketing and project management, not so much engineering...

Um...

Senior Project Manager/Engineer at General Motors
Business and Operation at General Motors
Project Engineer, Powertrain Integration at General Motors

Seriously, not so much engineering? And where do you get marketing from?

I see "Project Engineer". Project engineer's are typically paper pushers (managers, personnel/team coordination) not "real engineers".


LMS - 5.32853173672 (A True Skeptic (TM) is objective)
TBS - 10.0
Elevated from y_po idiot to moron, 11/8/09, 8:35 CST

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:20pm #16
jglix
EExtensive
Jerk
Registered: Sep, 2009
Last visit: Mon, 29 Mar 2010
Posts: 21

Y_Po wrote:

too pretty to be a real enhineer

If you were trying to be funny then that is hillarious!

If not, then not so much.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:21pm #17
hoarybat
EElevated
Registered: Dec, 2008
Last visit: 14 hours ago
Posts: 416

With posts like these the mystery just seems to deepen creating a seemingly larger divide between real or not real for the EESU. Why hire someone like this? To continue to perpetuate a scam or readying/positioning oneself for the great release/breakthrough. I have visited here less frequently since there was no new year announcement but posts like these are nice to see. Thanks..


Lensman Scale: 5.5 All truth passes through three stages: First, it is ridiculed; Second, it is violently opposed; and Third, it is accepted as self-evident.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:22pm #18
ShortEE
EEcclesiastical
Mrschadenfreude2
Registered: Apr, 2009
Last visit: 7 minutes ago
Posts: 1046

dfwrunner wrote:

I see "Project Engineer". Project engineer's are typically paper pushers (managers, personnel/team coordination) not "real engineers".

So your assertion is that she is not a "real engineer"?

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:24pm #19
Y_Po
EExhilarating
Zawy_y_go
Registered: May, 2009
Posts: 3239

Yeah, what is "project engineer"?


Q: What would happen if you give 12V battery and two 6V light bulbs to Weir/Nelson?

A: They will wait 8 years for 12V➜6V DC-DC converter.

http://theeestory.com/topics/3687
http://theeestory.com/topics/2105
http://theeestory.com/topics/4835

Online
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:28pm #20
eeOrange
EExpert
Orangelotus
Registered: Nov, 2009
Last visit: 5 hours ago
Posts: 124

With the tone/subject of the posts in the last 2 months, I have been alternating between laughing hysterically and pounding my head against the desktop until bloody. Really, I can quit this anytime; why does my family keep looking at me strangely?!?


8.5 on Lensmen Scale

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:29pm #21
dfwrunner
EEluminated
Eesuins
Registered: Aug, 2008
Last visit: 14 hours ago
Posts: 575

ShortEE wrote:

dfwrunner wrote:

I see "Project Engineer". Project engineer's are typically paper pushers (managers, personnel/team coordination) not "real engineers".

So your assertion is that she is not a "real engineer"?

Not at all, I'm saying that she had advanced beyond engineering into project management and that she was probably hired for a project management role rather than strictly engineering (e.g. designing circuits). "project engineer is a very common title for someone IN project management.


LMS - 5.32853173672 (A True Skeptic (TM) is objective)
TBS - 10.0
Elevated from y_po idiot to moron, 11/8/09, 8:35 CST

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:33pm #22
Y_Po
EExhilarating
Zawy_y_go
Registered: May, 2009
Posts: 3239

dfwrunner
Yeah, and unless this photo was taken 20 years ago she advanced into "project" engineering pretty damn quickly.

Zenn need to hire ugly old man to impress me


Q: What would happen if you give 12V battery and two 6V light bulbs to Weir/Nelson?

A: They will wait 8 years for 12V➜6V DC-DC converter.

http://theeestory.com/topics/3687
http://theeestory.com/topics/2105
http://theeestory.com/topics/4835

Online
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:39pm #23
cman
EExtensive
Registered: Dec, 2009
Last visit: Wed, 01 Sep 2010
Posts: 35

dfwrunner wrote:

ShortEE wrote:

dfwrunner wrote:

I see "Project Engineer". Project engineer's are typically paper pushers (managers, personnel/team coordination) not "real engineers".

So your assertion is that she is not a "real engineer"?

Not at all, I'm saying that she had advanced beyond engineering into project management and that she was probably hired for a project management role rather than strictly engineering (e.g. designing circuits). "project engineer is a very common title for someone IN project management.

A Project Manager must be capable of understanding all aspects of the works their engineers under them do. Project Engineers are usually very well accomplished Engineers that can work well with others (yes i know it's an oxymoron). Other Managers who don't need engineering skills are the ones that then supervise the Project Managers.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:41pm #24
cman
EExtensive
Registered: Dec, 2009
Last visit: Wed, 01 Sep 2010
Posts: 35

Y_Po wrote:

dfwrunner
Yeah, and unless this photo was taken 20 years ago she advanced into "project" engineering pretty damn quickly.


Zenn need to hire ugly old man to impress me

It's good to see your maturity finally catching up to your age.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:43pm #25
Bretspot
Administrator
Vaultdwellerbr_sm
Registered: Aug, 2008
Last visit: 26 minutes ago
Posts: 1212

Deniers are going to be http://i13.photobucket.com/albums/a276/abinidab/straws.jpg with this one for a while...


Read Bretspot's EEStor timeline
EEStor on Twitter
Never before have so many people understood so little about so much. James Burke

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:46pm #26
Y_Po
EExhilarating
Zawy_y_go
Registered: May, 2009
Posts: 3239

cman wrote:

Y_Po wrote:

dfwrunner
Yeah, and unless this photo was taken 20 years ago she advanced into "project" engineering pretty damn quickly.


Zenn need to hire ugly old man to impress me

It's good to see your maturity finally catching up to your age.


Do you have a point to make?


Q: What would happen if you give 12V battery and two 6V light bulbs to Weir/Nelson?

A: They will wait 8 years for 12V➜6V DC-DC converter.

http://theeestory.com/topics/3687
http://theeestory.com/topics/2105
http://theeestory.com/topics/4835

Online
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:48pm #27
PaulF
EEager
Registered: Sep, 2008
Last visit: 41 minutes ago
Posts: 305

Y_Po wrote:

dfwrunner
Yeah, and unless this photo was taken 20 years ago she advanced into "project" engineering pretty damn quickly.


Zenn need to hire ugly old man to impress me

hmmmm. Who do you suggest? I am old enough to be called old, but I am very handsome. How old are you? Maybe Abe Vigoda? He is not dead yet. :)


"Y_Po called me a moron. Eat it up you idiots!"

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:48pm #28
broschultz
EEluminated
Registered: May, 2009
Last visit: 3 hours ago
Posts: 532

In NY a professional engineer has to have either an engineering degree from an accredited engineering school or a lot of documented engineering experience plus must pass several written exams on different engineering subjects. "Practicing" the profession of engineering, like "practicing" medicine without a license is a crime in NY. That being said it's not difficult to pass the tests as they cover basic engineering problems.
There are experience requirments that must be met before you can sit for the tests.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 2:58pm #29
cman
EExtensive
Registered: Dec, 2009
Last visit: Wed, 01 Sep 2010
Posts: 35

broschultz wrote:

In NY a professional engineer has to have either an engineering degree from an accredited engineering school or a lot of documented engineering experience plus must pass several written exams on different engineering subjects. "Practicing" the profession of engineering, like "practicing" medicine without a license is a crime in NY. That being said it's not difficult to pass the tests as they cover basic engineering problems.
There are experience requirments that must be met before you can sit for the tests.

I was under the understanding that in the US you don't have to be accredited to use the title Engineer? Or is it you don't need the title to do equivalent work (you just can't use the title). I know up here in Canada you cannot do public engineering work or use the title without accreditation.

Also have you taken their tests before? I know the US is slightly easier than Canada's Electrical Engineering tests but I'm sure its still far from being 'not difficult'.

Offline
Fri, 22 Jan 2010, 3:04pm #30
brianjones
EErudite
Registered: Nov, 2009
Last visit: 3 hours ago
Posts: 72

broschultz wrote:

In NY a professional engineer has to have either an engineering degree from an accredited engineering school or a lot of documented engineering experience plus must pass several written exams on different engineering subjects. "Practicing" the profession of engineering, like "practicing" medicine without a license is a crime in NY. That being said it's not difficult to pass the tests as they cover basic engineering problems.
There are experience requirments that must be met before you can sit for the tests.

And is it me, or does this
"* Senior Project Manager/Engineer at General Motors"
not mean she was also an engineer at GM (and it would seem a damn good one)?

Offline